Having friends studying in both the institutes, I might be able to help you with the question. To conclude which is the best option for you, we have to first compare these two Institutes in the following few criteria.
Placement records:
Particulars |
SIBM Pune |
XIMB |
Number of students placed |
365 |
374 |
Number of recruiters |
84 |
97 |
Top recruiters |
ICICI Bank, Capgemini, Asian paints, Godrej. |
BNY Mellon, Accenture, Deloitte, Airtel. |
Highest CTC offered |
27 LPA |
24 LPA |
Average CTC offered |
16 LPA |
15.51 LPA |
Placement rate |
98% |
98% |
You have to assess all these factors, consider your personal commitments, course fee and other information about both of these Institutes to decide what is best for you.
When compared to the top IIMs, SPJIMR is a rather moderately good B School. Yet the placements and roles offered by the B School are at par with that of IIMs. The major USP of the B School is its profile-based evaluation. This means a certain candidate can make it into SPJIMR even if he was unable to get a high CAT or XAT score of 98-99 percentile provided that his profile is excellent. With the required skills, qualities, and a decent academic record you could get admission and meet not necessarily get a very high CAT score. This gives a wider spectrum for students to showcase their skills other than academics. There are some more key points where SPJIMR fares rather well when compared to IIMs or other B Schools.
Fees: The primary factor that distinguishes SPJIMR from the top B Schools is the moderate fees. SPJIMR PGDM fees for 2 years is ?20.42 Lakhs (Total Fees) while that of top IIMs is above 20 lakhs.
Placements: The entire placement drive is concluded quite fast and is at par with the top IIMs. SPJIMR Completes Final Placements 2023 with 46% Rise in Highest Salary at Rs. 77.8 LPA and 3% Rise in Average Salary at Rs. 33.02 LPA; Accenture, BCG, HUL, Godrej, ITC, KPMG, P&G being the major recruiters.
Batch size: This is an often underestimated aspect when in reality it affects both, placements and the quality of education. SPJIMR batch size is around 300 while that of most IIMs is 350-500. The low batch size results in better bonding between peers and close relations with the faculty.
Location: Located in the Finance capital of India, SPJIMR offers a plethora of advantages. Easy access to CXOs and practitioners gives the learning experience at SPJIMR a practical approach.
Curriculum: The curriculum is unique in the sense that it targets not just the student's IQ but also EQ and creates socially and emotionally aware managers. This unique course curriculum at SPJIMR offers three distinct levels of learning:
Pedagogy: Apart from the regular courses and teaching methodology employed at other premier B Schools, SPJIMR takes five key initiatives in the ‘Non-Classroom Learning’ area which include ADMAP, DOCC, Abhyudaya, PG Lab, and Science of Spirituality.
All these unique aspects make life at SPJIMR a very good experience compared to old IIMs.
There are many major reasons why ISB Hyderabad is not as popular as IIMs among Indian households. Some of them include
All these reasons are strong enough to persuade one against joining ISB Hyderabad and is thus not much popular among Indian households.
The reason why IIMs are popular in contrast to ISB Hyderabad are
So all this makes IIMs much popular in India despite ISB Hyderabad global rankings.
LNCT Bhopal is one of the top private engineering colleges located in Central India. Thus, joining LNCT Bhopal is a highly recommended institute for pursuing Information and Technology (IT). As some of my friends studied there, I am quite familiar with the institute’s performance.
Here is a brief insight about the placement reports of LNCT Bhopal:
Institute | IT at LNCT, Bhopal |
Placement Percentage | 80% |
Highest Salary Package | INR 22 LPA |
Average Salary Package | INR 9-10 LPA |
Top Recruiting Companies | Tech Mahindra, Microsoft, Amazon, Cognizant, Wipro, Infosys, TCS, Capgemini, etc. |
In case you are more inclined towards CSE, then choosing institutes like Oriental, Medi-caps, SIRT, TIT, and Acropolis can be a good choice as well, if not the best. But ultimately it is your decision, so select the one that best suits your interests.
VNIT, Nagpur and IIEST, Shibpur are two prime institutes of the nation and rank highly. Each has its own unique attractions and disadvantages. MME and ETC are highly demanded courses. While IIEST offers 64 seats for ETC, VNIT offers 115 seats for MME. NIRF has ranked IIEST at 21 whereas VNIT ranked at 27 among the NIRF Rankings
About the courses:
ETC graduates can work in various government jobs and a variety of development centers dealing in sales, manufacture, and services of electronics & communication customer appliances.
MME is a branch of engineering that is in huge demand. Metallurgical students can get placed in various research programs or the public and government sectors.
Admission:
The admission to both institutes is done on the basis of rank secured in the national level entrance examination i.e. JEE Main.
To be eligible for admission, one must secure 75% marks in aggregate in their intermediate graduation.
Placement Statistics
IIEST: The highest package offered to IIEST students was INR 39.12 LPA. 61.9% of the ETC students were placed. Some major companies that recruit students from IIEST are Accenture, ICICI Bank, Cognizant, Microsoft, Maruti, and PWC.
VNIT: The highest package offered in campus placements was 22 LPA. 50% of the MME students were placed in recruitments. Top recruiters at this institute include L&T ECC, Reliance Industries, Deloitte, JP Morgan, Aditya Birla Group.
Facilities
IIEST: The institute offers facilities such as halls of residence, Library, Labs, Canteen, School, etc. It also provides medical facilities like hospitals and ambulances, sports and games clubs, and entrepreneurship activities.
VNIT: Students are offered Hostels, Guesthouse, Gymnasium, Sports, Health Centre, and Library facilities within the 215 acres campus. There are clubs and community shops as well.
Students must compare both the programs and colleges carefully. The decision depends on an individual’s capabilities and expectations from college life.
You should choose Manav Rachna University over NIET for B.Tech in CSE. Here are the reasons why.
The decision will largely depend on what factors are more important to you. I’ll try and give you an overall analysis of the facts and figures of both the colleges in the table below:
Particulars |
IBS Hyderabad |
Jaipuria Noida |
Fee |
16.02 Lakhs |
8 Lakhs |
Highest Package |
19.18 LPA |
22 LPA |
Average Package |
8 LPA |
11.52 LPA |
Batch Size |
1200 |
300 |
Jaipuria noida seems better in every aspect unless you specifically wants to go to IBS Hyderabad.
It is subjective because it depends on many factors like your goals, preferences, and any other individual constraints you might have. It is hard to compare as both are among the top B-schools in India but below is a table comparing the two in different aspects;
Parameters |
SPJIMR Mumbai |
IIM Calcutta |
Fees |
INR 20.42 Lakhs |
INR 23 Lakhs |
Highest Salary |
INR 77.8 LPA |
Not out yet |
Median Salary |
INR 32.89 LPA |
INR 33.67 LPA |
Average Salary |
INR 33.02 LPA |
INR 35.07 LPA |
Exams accepted |
CAT/GMAT |
CAT |
Batch Size |
300 |
280 |
Top Recruiters |
Asian Paints, Hindustan Unilever Limited, ITC, Accenture Strategy |
Adobe, Flipkart, Amazon, BCG, Goldman Sachs |
IIM Calcutta has slightly higher tuition costs than SPJIMR Mumbai. Different courses are offered by each business school, and IIMC offers more options than SPJIMR Mumbai.
Although IIM Calcutta has a little higher median income than SPJIMR Mumbai, both institutions' average salaries are on par with those of the top IIMs. While the batch size of IIM Kolkata is not shown in the search results, SPJIMR Mumbai has a comparatively modest batch size.
Chitkara university Rajpura is a globally recognized organization promoting academic excellence through entering disciplinary applied research. The university offers various undergraduate, postgraduate, and Ph.D. programs. The college provides a BE program in CSE and the total course fee is 9.9 lakhs. The admission is through JEE Main.
Chitkara university Baddi is a very famous nonprofitable university in North India. It is approved by UGC and accredited by NAAC with a’ B’ Grade. The BE CSE program at the institute costs around 5.6 lakhs. The admission is based on the performance of the students in JEE Main.
Faculty:
Chitkara University, Rajpur:
The faculty at the Department of Computer Science and engineering at Chitkara university Rajpura are very helpful and they are alumni of prestigious universities.
Almost all the faculty members hold a Ph.D. in their respective fields.
Chitkara university Baddi:
The faculty at the department of CSE in Chitkara university Baddi is very well qualified.
Maximum of the faculty members are Ph.D. holders in their field. Teachers are friendly and guide students for their overall development.
Placements:
Chitkara University, Rajpur:
Placement drive at Chitkara university Rajpura is known to welcome prominent recruiters such as Google, Amazon, Infosys, Samsung, Fortis, oracle, Adobe, Bharat petroleum, Aditya Birla group, HDFC, Taj Hotels, Tata, Mahindra, etc.
The highest package 2019 placements were 32 lacs per annum.
Around 90% of students from the engineering stream got placed.
Chitkara university Baddi:
Almost 80 to 90% of students got a place from Chitkara university Baddi. The highest salary package offered varies from 16 to 17 lacs per annum.
Mass recruiting companies like TCS, Wipro, Infosys visit the college frequently.
Around 500 companies visited the campus to offer placements to students in last year’s placement drive.
Infrastructure:
Chitkara University, Rajpur:
Chitkara university Rajpura provides Wi-Fi in every department and the classrooms with the capacity to hold 60 students.
Different libraries are available for different departments.
Chitkara university Baddi:
Infrastructure at Chitkara University Baddi is also good. Wi-Fi is available in each part of the university.
The laboratories are well-equipped to carry out academic and research works.
The details discussed above, about the two Universities, will help you in making a decision as to which college you must opt to. However, the requirements are to be considered like the fee structure and eligibility to ensure your chances of getting admitted.
If you want to see rank-wise, of course, IIT Roorkee is the best option and you will notice a difference in a variety of parameters, but IIT Hyderabad is also a good option because it has good faculty members and offers all advanced courses. Placements are also good here. As a result, both are relatively similar.
Both are excellent Mtech programs, but IIT Roorkee has an advantage over IIT Hyderabad due to the older IIT and its superior research environment.