Get Answers on Test Preparation, Admissions & Campus Life
Study Abroad Countries
Which college to choose from IIM Raipur or SCMHRD for Marketing? Please help.
When considering whether to attend IIM Raipur or another institute, it is important to consider a variety of factors. Both IIM Raipur and SCMHRD offer good placement opportunities for Marketing, however, the faculty and the curriculum may differ. It is recommended to attend lectures and evaluate which institute's faculty aligns more with your learning style and goals.
IIM Raipur has a strong reputation in the field of marketing and has won several marketing-related business school competitions over the years, making it a good choice for students interested in this domain.
From a long-term perspective, having an IIM tag on your resume can be beneficial. It makes you a part of a larger alumni pool and can open up many opportunities in the future. Many premium job portals have a criterion of "IIMs/ISB/XLRI/MDI only" for certain job openings, which could be a factor to consider when looking for post-MBA job opportunities.
It is important to keep in mind that the choice ultimately depends on the individual student's priorities and preferences. The information provided is only a guide to help in the decision-making process.
For an MBA HR, should we choose IIM Ranchi (PGDMHRM) or SCMHRD?
To answer your question in better terms I will rate the colleges based on parameters such as placements, curriculum, and alumni base.
- TISS / XLRI - TISS has an advantage owing to its smaller batch and location in a metro (Mumbai). XLRI excels in the Alumni network and the variety of roles offered. In addition, the option of getting a Non-HR profile after an MBA has increased its ranking considerably.
- MDI Gurgaon - After this, MDI Gurgaon bags the position because of its location and strong alumni base.
- SCMHRD - It is a decent college but the quality of the crowd is substandard when compared to IIMs.
- Newer IIMs like Ranchi
- IMI & other colleges
Which one is better, IMT Ghaziabad (marketing) or SCMHRD (business analytics)?
In a post-graduation program in management, IMT Ghaziabad is generally considered to be a better-known and recognized brand than SCMHRD (Symbiosis Centre for Management and Human Resource Development). This is due to a number of factors, such as the institute's reputation for providing students with a strong foundation in management through its curriculum, industry-relevant courses, and practical training. Additionally, the institute's alumni network of industry leaders can help students to secure internships and job opportunities post-graduation.
IMT Ghaziabad is particularly well-known for its marketing program, which is considered to be one of the best in the country. The program is designed to provide students with a comprehensive understanding of the various aspects of marketing, such as consumer behavior, market research, and branding. Additionally, the institute's focus on providing students with practical training through internships, industry projects, and case studies, helps students to develop the skills and knowledge needed to excel in a career in marketing.
On the other hand, SCMHRD also offers a strong program in management, but it might not be as recognized as IMT Ghaziabad, specifically in Marketing. Additionally, SCMHRD offers a course in Business Analytics which is considered a niche course, and it's not as widely offered as Marketing at different B-schools.
It's important to research the different options available and weigh the pros and cons of each institute. Researching the institute's curriculum, faculty, and alumni network, as well as speaking to current students and alumni can help you to make an informed decision. Additionally, it would be a good idea to seek the opinion of professionals in the field you are interested in, as they can provide valuable insights into the opportunities and challenges of different career paths. It's also important for you to decide whether you want to join a niche course that you are passionate about or a more general one.
Which is best for MBA HR: SIBM Pune or NMIMS Mumbai or SCMHRD?
The colleges that you have mentioned are quite old and reputed, leaving behind a history of a great placement record and a bright future.
Human Resources has become a promising field in today’s time. A good HR assures that the aspects of the business they work for proves to be fulfilled along with allowing the employees their own space wherein they give importance to the clients.
Based on certain parameters, allow me to compare all the three institutes so that it gets convenient to choose the B-School of your choice.
| Categories | SIBM Pune | NMIMS Mumbai | SCMHRD |
| Course Fee | 17.26 lakh | 6.04 lakh | 11.94 lakh |
| Highest CTC | 35 LPA | 16 LPA | 18-21 LPA |
| Average CTC | 18 LPA | 8 LPA | 10 LPA |
| Recruiting Companies | Crisil, HSBC, etc. | Berger, ITC, etc. | Mindtree, ICICI Bank, etc. |
My suggestion would be to consider NMAT and even SNAP so that you get a better view to choose from. Some promising prospects are indeed offered by NMIMS and SIBM-P, but I believe you should go for that particular institute which is reputed for its HR department.
Which is the better option, SIBM Pune or SCMHRD?
In terms of ranking and brand value, SIBM Pune is better than SCMHRD. India Today 2021 has ranked SIBM Pune and SCMHRD 7th and 8th for MBA respectively. But rather than ranking and brand recognition, you should put more importance on the course you are going to pursue.
If you are planning on pursuing MBA Business Analytics, MBA HR, or MBA Infrastructure Management, then you should go for SCMHRD. For the Marketing specialization, both of these two are decent options.
Which will be a better choice, NICMAR, RICS, SCMHRD IM, or XIMB UMG?
NICMAR, RICS, SCMHRD, and XIMB all of these are reputed management institutes in India. NICMAR conducts NCAT and SCMHRAD conducts SNAP to take admission. Whereas, XIMB and RICS select students based on their performance in CAT/XAT/GMAT, etc.
Rankings:
-
NICMAR is ranked 1st amongst the top colleges in ASIA.
-
RICS, Amity University is one of the six Indian institutes which have made it to QS Asian University Rankings.
-
SCMHRD is ranked 4th state wise and city wise in 2020 by the Indian Institutional Ranking Framework (IIRF).
-
XIMB, Xavier University Bhubaneswar has been ranked 10th amongst All India Private B-School by IT-MDRA B-School Ranking 2019.
Placements:
Highlights of the placements at the institutes are as follows.
|
Criteria |
NICMAR |
RICS |
SCMHRD IM |
XIMB UMG |
|
Placement Percentage |
99.2 |
93 |
90 |
100 |
|
Highest Package (INR) |
13 LPA |
32 LPA |
15.4 LPA |
9.36 LPA |
Top Recruiters:
-
NICMAR: Adventz Group, Rabico Engg. & Construction, Reliance Industries Ltd, AFCONS Infrastructure Ltd, Synergy group, etc.
-
RICS: Turner & Townsend, AECOM, Rider Levett Bucknall, Formulaic Engineers Pvt. Ltd, GMR, and many more.
-
SCMHRD IM: Deloitte, Cognizant, Amazon, Vodafone, Kotak Life, Google, IBM, Cipla, Godrej, and many more.
-
XIMB XUB: Tractebel GKW GmbH, Recity Network Pvt. Ltd., Convexicon Software SolutionsIndia Pvt. Ltd., CURE, etc.
Facilities:
NICMAR:
-
It has a library with a rich collection of more than 23000 thesis, 2300+ volumes, 495 teaching notes, 13 e-resources, and 75 printed periodicals.
-
Other facilities like hostels, 24x7 wifi connections for computer labs and classrooms, auditorium, 3 conference halls, and outdoor sports facilities are offered.
RICS:
-
The institute has more than 100 faculty members and 1000+ students studying on the campus.
-
Classrooms with new-age teaching tools, computer labs, a library with 2 lakh+ books, periodicals, references to international and national journals, food courts, and cafeteria are the facilities offered by the institute.
SCMHRD:
-
Scholarships are offered only to students of MBA who top the first semester A total of 50% tuition fee waiver is covered by the scholarship.
-
The institute has a health center with specialized doctors, a yoga center and gymnasium, hostels, a library with a huge collection of more than 2000 audio and video files, 24000 books, and periodicals.
XIMB UGB:
-
Library, residential facility, medical help, sports, fitness facility, and professional audio-video studios are the facilities offered.
NICMAR, RICS, SCMHRD, and XIMB all these colleges are highly reputed and have nailed down their efficiency in terms of education, placements as well as all the factors required for the development of the student’s academics and career.
Among all the Symbiosis business schools present in Pune, which are the better ones apart from SIBM-Pune and SCMHRD?
Except SIBM-Pune and SCMHRD, all SIIB, SIDTM, and SCIT colleges are the best Symbiosis business schools present in Pune. The admission process is the same for all and is based on entrance tests followed by personal interview and group discussion.
Ranking
- SIIB, Pune holds rank 59th among the best business schools in India issued by Career Launcher.
- SIDTM, Pune holds 17th rank for Business schools in the western region issued by The Week.
- SCIT, Pune holds 7th rank for MBA issued by Analytics India Magazine.
Tabulated below gives a brief overview of both institutions:
|
Particulars |
SIIB |
SIDTM |
SCIT |
|
No. of seats |
210 |
150 |
180 |
|
Top recruiters |
ITC ABD, VMware, Zydex Industries, Darashaw, Accenture, Merck (MSD), HDFC Bank, Dun and Bradstreet, , BOX 8, Michael Page, Axis Bank |
Accenture, Aditya Birla Group, Airtel, Capgemini, Cognizant, CRISIL, Deloitte, HCL Technologies |
ACCENTURE, American Express, Axis Bank, Capgemini, Deloitte, Ernst & Young, EXL Services, Gartner, HCL Comnet |
|
Average salary |
10.60 lakhs |
11.60 lakhs |
11.1 lakhs |
Admission process
- The admission process is wholly online with an application fee of 1000 INR.
- Admission for MBA in this university is based on an entrance test known as SNAP followed by a written ability test, personal interview, and group discussion.
- With this students are required to have a graduate degree with 50%.
Placements
SIIB, Pune
- Companies like ITC ABD, VMware, Zydex Industries, Darashaw, Accenture, Merck (MSD), HDFC Bank, Dun and Bradstreet, BOX 8, Michael Page, Axis Bank, HDFC Life, etc visit the campus every year.
- The average salary package offered is up to 10.60 lakhs and the highest salary package is up to 19.50 lakhs.
SIDTM, Pune
- Companies like Accenture, Aditya Birla Group, Airtel, Capgemini, Cognizant, CRISIL, Deloitte, HCL Technologies, IBM, etc visit the campus for good placements.
- The average salary package is 11.06 lakhs and the highest salary package is up to 16.50 lakhs.
SCIT, Pune
- Companies like Accenture, American Express, Axis Bank, Capgemini, Deloitte, Ernst & Young, EXL Services, Gartner, HCL Comnet, and so on come every year for placements.
- The average salary package is up to 10 lakhs and the highest package is up to 31 lakhs.
Overall all colleges of Symbiosis are equally good at their place. All business schools provide good facilities, Infrastructure of institutes are also pretty well maintained. All institutes provide 100 % placements to students. The teachers are very helpful and kind. The environment of the schools is also friendly and engaging.
NMIMS, SCMHRD or SIBM Pune, which would be better for Finance — learning, competitions, placements wise?
Narsee Monjee Institute of Management Studies (NMIMS) institute is one of the best management universities in India. Admissions in this university are based on qualifying exams NPATand NMAT followed by personal interview and counseling.
Symbiosis Institute of Business Management (SIBM) Pune is one of the best business schools in India. Admission to this university is based on an entrance test known as Symbiosis National Aptitude Test (SNAP) followed by personal interview and group discussion.
Symbiosis Center for Management & Human Resource Development (SCMHRD) holds 13th rank for MBA issued by times. Admissions for MBA are based on an entrance test followed by a personal interview and group discussion.
Placements
Narsee Monjee Institute of Management Studies (NMIMS)
- Companies like Bank of America, Barclays, EY, Deloitte, Vedanta, Accenture, Aditya Birla, Amdocs, Google, Deloitte, etc visit the campus every year. Last year about 166 companies visited.
- Approximately the average salary package offered to students of this university was up to 17.97 lakhs and the highest salary package offered is 30.37 lakhs
SCMHRD
- Companies like Accenture, Accenture, Avalon Consulting, Axis Bank, Bajaj Auto, Barclays Bank, Bridgei2, Capgemini, CITI Bank, etc visited campus for placements.
- The average salary package is up to 15.6 lakhs and the highest package salary is up to 38.5 lakhs.
Symbiosis Institute of Business Management (SIBM) Pune
- Companies like Airtel, Capgemini, Samsung, Accenture, Wipro, HSBC, Dell, etc visit the campus every year in search of good placements.
- The average salary package offered to students is up to 20.08 lakhs and the highest salary package is up to 34.26 lakhs.
Infrastructure and faculty
NMIMS
- Hospital, sports ground, Wi-Fi facility, well-equipped labs, and all necessary facilities are available on campus.
- Teachers are well-qualified, knowledgeable, and very helpful.
SCMHRD
- The university has a huge and beautiful campus.
- The teachers are very helpful and kind.
- The environment of the university is also friendly and engaging.
SIBM
- University has a huge campus with all necessary facilities like equipped labs, sports ground, spacious classrooms, Wi-Fi facilities, and others.
- Teachers are very knowledgeable and well experienced in their particular fields.
Overall all institutes are good for and the admission process of all institutes is also not that tough. But if we particularly talk about placements then NMIMS and SIBM are better than SCMHRD and NMIMS even has a record of 100% placement last year. With this, all institutes have an engaging and encouraging environment.
Is an MBA in Business Analytics from SCMHRD or an MBA from SIBM Bangalore worth it?
Yes, pursuing an MBA in Business Analytics from SCMHRD or an MBA from SIBM Bangalore can be rewarding.
MBA in Business Analytics is a comparatively new course at SCMHRD, but it has performed exceptionally well, in last few years. This course covers R, Python, MySQL, Tableau, and the application of these subjects in other subjects like Marketing Analytics, Operation Analytics, Risk Analytics, etc. There are also subjects related to Machine Learning, Artificial Intelligence, Big Data, Data Mining, etc. Here are some details regarding SCMHRD Business Analytics. The course includes a mandatory live project. Through the live project, you will get to work with different companies.
- SNAP Cutoff - 97
- Placements - Highest CTC for MBA BA - INR 22 LPA, Average CTC for MBA BA - INR 15.8 LPA
SIBM Bangalore MBA is also a good option in terms of placements, faculty and ROI. According to the 2021 highlights of SIBM Bangalore MBA placements, the median CTC was INR 10 LPA. While INR 32 LPA was the highest CTC offered by the recruiters.
As compared to SIBM, Pune, where does SCMHRD, Pune stand?
SIBM Pune has a slight edge over SCMHRD. It is the first campus of Symbiosis and has a legacy of more than four decades. It has a wider and stronger alumni network. The cutoff for the two campuses varies only by 0.2-0.4 percentile with SIBM having the higher cutoff most years.
SIBM Pune placements have been pretty good over the last few years. According to the placement highlights of 2022, the average CTC offered to the students was INR 23.06 LPA. The highest CTC offered was INR 45.5 LPA.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWS LETTER
