Mechanical/Electrical Engineering is superior to Production Engineering because Mechanical engineers can apply for jobs in the field of Production, whereas Production engineers cannot apply for core Mechanical jobs.
So, instead of selecting Production, I will recommend Mechanical /Electrical at NIT Durgapur in this case.
Here is a brief outline of NIT Durgapur.
Average CTC | 9 LPA |
Highest CTC | 33 LPA |
Major recruiters | TCS, IEM, Vedanta, TATA IQ, etc. |
Course fee | 5.56 lakhs |
Choose between Mechanical and Electrical based on your interests.
My answer is from the perspective of an FPM aspirant. To draw a fair comparison I have considered the following parameters
Hostel:
The hostel facility at IIM Kozhikode is not very good. The first-year students have no married accommodation while the second or third-year students have very limited married accommodation. Sometimes the FPM students are adjusted with PGP students which is very disturbing.
IIM Lucknow has 2 spectate buildings for FPM students. Also, married accommodations are available from the 1 st year itself.
Food:
There is no active mess committee to pay heed to the complaints regarding substandard food. The menu is usually North Indian and is rarely followed properly. Limited South Indian food is available. Options outside the mess are also limited and not as per the taste of many.
IIM Lucknow has an active mess committee that takes care of the food and cleanliness of the mess. The menu has a variety of options and is changed every month to break the monotony. Famous for its food, there are many options to eat outside in Lucknow.
Academics:
The academics are very rigorous at IIM Kozhikode with tight schedules and deadlines. For FPM students, the minimum passing criteria are B- (2.67/4.33) which is 62% passing criteria. Whereas the minimum criteria to award a Ph.D. degree is at least one publication in “B” (ABDC) category journals.
IIM Lucknow has a relatively less rigorous curriculum than Kozhikode. The minimum passing criteria are 50%. Whereas the minimum criteria to award a Ph.D. degree is at least one publication in “C” (ABDC) category journals.
Apart from these major differences, the infrastructure, faculty, and college life are almost the same. So you can make a good choice now.
According to the 2020 NIRF rankings, MNNIT Allahabad is ranked 48th among the top engineering institutes in India. It offers specializations in Computer Science & Engineering, Software Engineering, and Information Security.
IIIT Bangalore is ranked 62nd and offers postgraduate specializations in Theory and Systems for Computing and Data, Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning, Networking and Communication, VLSI Systems, and Digital Society.
IIIT Delhi is ranked 56th and offers 2 years M.Tech in CSE with specializations in Information Security, Data Engineering, Mobile Computing, and Artificial Intelligence.
Admission:
Course Fees:
Apart from tuition fees, there are additional fees payable for IIIT Delhi and IIIT Bangalore.
Placement:
Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Walmart, Amazon, Flipkart, Oracle, Cisco, Citrix, Samsung, Google, Microsoft, IBM, Qualcomm, Adobe, etc. are some of the companies visiting all the three campuses. So, choosing either of the institutes on the basis of visiting recruiters is not an issue.
Listed below are the placement statistics for each of the institute:
Institutes | Highest Package | Average Package |
MNNIT Allahabad | INR 22 LPA | INR 10 LPA |
IIIT Bangalore | INR 43.31 LPA | INR 24.76 LPA |
IIIT Delhi | INR 36 LPA | INR 16.27 LPA |
All three institutes are nationally ranked and offer M.Tech in CSE with specializations in different fields as mentioned above. So, the choice of institute solely lies with the students by considering the stated facts and statistics.
If you are opting to go for Business Analytics, then pursuing it from Chandigarh University will be better.
One of my cousins is a student of Chandigarh University, pursuing Business Analytics, and asserts how great the exposure she has been receiving there. Here is what she has to say about the course.
Other companies that visit CU are Deloitte, IDBI bank, Shopclues, Oracle India, PeopleScout, TechMahindra, Flipkart, Hafele India, Markets and Markets Research Pvt Ltd, Aditya Birla Fashion and Retails, Crescendo, Essar Services India Private Limited, Bandhan Bank.
CUSAT SOE Mechanical is better than FISAT. It is among the most reputed technological institutes in the region. CUSAT offers excellent facilities and opportunities. The Mechanical department has a brilliant faculty base.
According to CUSAT placements of recent years, the average CTC for Mechanical branch is around INR 5 LPA. Godrej, L&T, Vedanta, etc. are among the core companies that recruit through the campus drive. PSU and IT companies also recruit Mechanical Students.
IIIT Guwahati is way better than IIIT Kalyani. Many of the students who were formerly enrolled in IIIT Kalyani. They left the college after analyzing the faculty, infrastructure, and hostel facilities.
My brother was in NIT Silchar before being a part of IIIT Guwahati. He went there and found out that many students were from IIIT Kalyani. Everyone has different reasons for leaving Kalyani. However, none of them were praising IIIT Kalyani.
On the other hand, they were pleased to join IIIT Guwahati. Some factors that make IIITG a better institute than IIIT Kalyani:
Hence, you can definitely go for IIITG as an institute rather than joining IIIT Kalyani. As far as the branches are concerned, CSE and ECE are totally different. But, at the end of the day, you have to decide which college you want to join. If you give more preference to the branch, you should join IIIT Kalyani but if you feel like you can slide or change your branch after the first year, you can join IIITG.
XIMB is better than IIM Udaipur. It is an old B-School with years of legacy. XIMB has a strong brand presence in the industry. All major MNCs visit the campus placement and offers tier-1 job profiles. More than 355 recruiters visited XIMB placements in 2022. The average CTC offered this year was INR 17.54 LPA. The highest CTC offered this year was INR 32.21 LPA.
XIMB is a better choice in terms of academics, placements, and exposure.
Among the mentioned two colleges, Shaheed Bhagat Singh College (SBSC) will be a better choice for B.Com (Hons.).
Categories | B.Com at SBSC | B.Com at DSC |
Course Fee | INR 23,000 | INR 27,000 |
Placement Percentage | 80-90% | 78% |
Highest CTC | 15 LPA | 20 LPA |
Average CTC | 8 LPA | 4.8 LPA |
Recruiting Companies | KPMG, Wipro, JSW, BYJU's etc. | TCS, Wipro, Infosys, HCL, etc. |
Dyal Singh College (DSC) is good but when compared to SBSC, it is more of a second option for commerce students after SBSC.
In my opinion, the best option among the given colleges is SCMHRD’s finance. I am not saying this on my own, but the data reflects the results. Let’s check the final placements for each college in the finance area.
The average package offered in the finance area at IMI Delhi is 17.64 lac per annum for the last batch. For IMT Ghaziabad, this figure is 14 LPA. XIMB is a little better than these colleges, with an average package of 20 LPA, but SCMHRD excels all of these with an average package of 22 LPA and the highest package of 27 LPA.
The main purpose of pursuing an MBA is to elevate your current profile and render you better career opportunities. Doing an MBA just for your resume or because everyone is doing it is not justifiable. And honestly, neither of the two colleges you mentioned has the potential to enhance your employability skills. So I would right away say that both these are not good options.
The reason why IIM Sambalpur is not worth it is mainly because being a new IIM, its tag has little or no brand value. Its overall worth is also very less in comparison to other IIMs. Most importantly, if you were able to get into a new IIM, chances are you can even get into an older, better one with a tad bit more effort and determination. So you can try again next year and join a better one.
The reason why XIMB is not worth it is because of ROI. The high fees compared to mediocre packages that are offered make no sense. You can get similar packages at a tier 2 college with much fewer fees.
Still, if you are under pressure to choose one, definitely go for IIM Sambalpur. The IIM tag might come in handy someday in our country whose corporates still value the tag more than the potential.